News Ticker

Supergirl – S1E16 – Falling

Previously on Supergirl, ‘‘Solitude’

Things are looking up for the DEO when Senator Crane visits to congratulate (and flirt with) Hank and let him know that she plans to fight for more funding and support for their agency. But when an emergency strikes, Kara has to fly into the city to rescue a fireman trapped by debris in a fire. Unfortunately, when she does so, she begins to feel odd—as it turns out, there is a random chunk of Red Kryptonite nearby.

Shaking it off, she goes to visit James at work and learns that Lucy has quit and left National City. James says that maybe he didn’t love her as much as she should have. Kara’s eyes widen, seeing a potential opportunity.

Meanwhile, Cat goes to visit The Talk. And as awkward and contrived as it felt, it was amusing to see her chat with the hosts about her relationship with Supergirl.

The Talk

Images: CBS/Screenshots

The next morning, Kara arrives for work dressed up way more than usual, acting all big and bad. When Cat asks Siobhan for the list she was supposed to assemble of replacements for Lucy, Kara reveals she had beaten her to it, and seems to enjoy humiliating Siobhan.

When she visits the DEO later, Hank is briefing his team about another Fort Rozz escapee named K’hund. Kara continues to act strangely… as Hank outlines the plan to capture K’hund, Supergirl nearly outs his identity as the Martian Manhunter. Then later, when they make their move, Supergirl easily gets the upper hand but chooses to let K’hund go because he bores her.

Red Faced

She lashes out at Hank about being under-appreciated, mostly because he is just as strong as she is but chooses not to do anything. Why, she asks, is she the only one putting her safety on the line? It’s a good question, and seems to get Hank thinking.

The next day, Siobhan reveals to Cat that she has footage of Supergirl letting K’hund escape. Cat tells her to keep it under wraps for the time being, but Siobhan immediately offers it to Perry White instead. Continuing her mean streak, Kara overhears this and prints off an incriminating email for Cat to read, which makes Cat fire Siobhan and burn her bridge with Perry White as well.

Kara and James Dance

That night, after coming on way too strong to James at a dance club, Supergirl goes to visit Cat, who had summoned her through James. She tells Cat that she is no longer interested in being a hero because it enables everyone’s victimhood. She goes off on Cat for being a self-serving egoist.

Then, to prove her point about “real power,” she hurls Cat off the balcony.

Catching CatIt was a terrifying moment for Cat, no doubt, but even though we all knew Kara wouldn’t actually let her die, it was still strange to see Cat taken down a few pegs.

During all of this, James and Winn decide to alert Hank and Alex about the changes in Kara’s behavior. Hank looks over Supergirl’s previous few missions and discovers a red, radioactive substance at the fire site.

Maxwell arrives—right on time—and admits that the red kryptonite was his creation. According to him, it was made to stop Non’s next attack, and he was just as surprised to see its effects on Supergirl. So he offers to make an antidote.

When Alex goes to visit Kara at her apartment, Kara tears into Alex, letting out years of pent-up resentment. She’s decided to make the city worship her. Meanwhile, Cat reluctantly goes on air to declare that she can no longer endorse Supergirl. This obviously pains her–she keeps dabbing her eyes.

Hank dispatches a team to track and take down the now rogue-Supergirl with Lord’s antidote. And when they find her, we get the money-shot of this season: with Alex incapacitated and about to be murdered by her sister, the only way Hank can save the day is if he morphs into J’onn.

Hank is MM

Of course, since the DEO’s mission is to take down aliens, Hank is immediately arrested.

Later, when Kara wakes up, she is horrified to remember her behavior over the last few days. Once again proving that she was always supposed to play this role, Benoist is quite convincing at showing Supergirl’s remorse, humiliation and regret.

She tries to apologize to James, and almost lets slip that she loves him, but James has decided to take some space for a while. With one more apology to deliver, Supergirl goes to pay Cat a visit. Cat resumes her role as Supergirl’s surrogate mother and says that if anyone can win back National City’s trust, it’s her. Then the two sit together for a while.

Supergirl S1E16
  • 8/10
    Plot - 8/10
  • 8/10
    Dialogue - 8/10
  • 8/10
    Action - 8/10
  • 10/10
    Performances - 10/10


I wasn’t expecting much from this episode. Smallville did similar storylines a lot, if I recall correctly. “Oh, look, the good guy has gone bad.” But I ended up enjoying it a lot more than I anticipated, mostly due to the performances of Melissa Benoist and Calista Flockhart. The scene in which Supergirl breaks down after admitting to Alex that everything she did was a result of deeply held secrets was touching, as was her attempt to apologize to Cat.

My issues are nothing new… I think it’s ridiculous for Cat to not know that her assistant is Supergirl and for Clark/Superman to just sit idly by as his cousin declares herself God of National City.

In response to the first, the only explanation is that Kara and Cat do not actually have the relationship we think they do. Is it possible that the two really don’t interact as much as we think? Maybe the only times they talk to each other is what we see on-screen—maybe three to four minutes a day, tops. Her insistence at calling her “Kira” would seem to support this idea. And in response to the second, I think it is only a matter of time before we see Clark in person. We’ll probably get a feel for how it would happen in the upcoming The Flash crossover, but with the new movie coming out it just has to happen at some point.

User Review
5 (1 vote)

About Adam Czarnecki (32 Articles)
Adam Czarnecki is as a technical communicator who lives in lower Michigan with his wife, son, and a few random animals. His first foray into fandom came during the early days of AOL when he began posting stories that featured his own adventures in the Star Trek universe. A recovering author of fan fiction, in the days of MySpace he wrote blogs about LOST that became quite popular despite the fact that none of his theories about the island were ultimately proven true. Since then, he has earned a Master’s degree in 2015 thanks in part to his interest in comic books, which served as the inspiration for his final project. Satisfied with this bio, he ends it here.

1 Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Supergirl – S1E17 – Manhunter | Project Fandom

Leave a comment